|
← Revision 13 as of 2002-01-11 14:25:05
Size: 2505
Comment:
|
← Revision 14 as of 2002-01-17 09:31:31 →
Size: 2609
Comment:
|
| Deletions are marked like this. | Additions are marked like this. |
| Line 34: | Line 34: |
|
could you test a lucent and/or cisco card just to give some comparison? --Forrest English |
Comments on the Proxim RangeLAN-DS PCMCIA Prism2Card:
Originally we were hoping that this card was a rebranded Zcomax XI-300 (see ZcomaxXi300Comments). However MichaelCodanti reports that:
I just got my 20 Proxim RangeLan-DS 8434-05 cards...
The good news:
- They are Zcomax XI-300's and have a snap off antenna with two Reverse MMCX connectors
Update 1/11/2002 ErikWalthinsen verified that they work under Linux as both clients and APs. (At least after forcing an update to the 0.8.3 firmware) Details here: [http://lists.personaltelco.net/pipermail/ptp/2002q1/011140.html]
Now for the bad news:
- The sticker says they have firmware 0.7.6, where the new Zcomax ones have 0.8.3.
Now for the REALLY bad news:
These are 3.3 volt cards, not 5 volt. (They are like the D-Link cards) But even worse, the cards are keyed correctly (unlike the D-Link ones) so they won't even go into the slot on my Toshiba 430CDT or a Stylistic 1000.
This could be good news for some embedded boxes(if they support 3.3 volt) as I think the 3.3 volt cards draw less power.
I, also, got 2 Proxim RangeLan-DS 8433-05 cards. They are almost the same as the above 8434-05 cards but the have an integrated antenna with a single connector of unknown type (maybe SSMB). They still come with old firmware and are 3.3 volt.
NOTES: With a little coaxing you can get Windows to update the firmware on these cards. I had to use drivers from Zcomax (had to hack the .inf file) and then I used the firmware update tool from Addtron as Zcomax hasn't released the 0.8.3 firmware they ship on their cards 
They have released a newer one but you can't use it until they release newer drivers to match.
Here is some sample signal numbers from using cards in an iPaq running PocketPC all using the same driver (Compaq's Prism driver) and everything:
Card |
Signal Quality |
Link Quality |
Notes |
D-Link DWL-650 |
33% |
6% |
Couldn't maintain a link to the AP |
Proxim RangeLan-DS 8433-05 |
40% |
26% |
Dropped the link once |
Proxim RangeLan-DS 8434-05 |
53% |
46% |
No problems at all |
Zcomax XI-300 |
53% |
46% |
No problems at all |
Above numbers are all the best I saw from the card while holding the iPaq in the same spot in my house connecting back to an AirPort base.
- could you test a lucent and/or cisco card just to give some comparison? --Forrest English
I think the Lucent cards are still better, but the Zcomax and Proxim cards with the snap off antenna appear to almost as well.